Social Presence Showdown: FedEx vs UPS

First, the data dump…

When it comes to followers and fans, FedEx is leading the way on Twitter with 247K followers to UPS’s 189K. On Facebook, UPS is a clear winner with 1.59M fans compared to its rivals 1.07M fans.

Looking beyond these two social networks to gain an overview of all mentions across the web, we found a total of 397,110 mentions in the last 3 months.

As the follower numbers would predict, UPS easily gains more of the conversation, with 60% of the mentions.

---

Sentiment analysis

An overview of the automated sentiment analysis reveals that as a percentage of total brand mentions, FedEx gained more positive mentions over the three month period.

While sentiment analysis isn’t perfect, it can give us an indication of any major issues to investigate, and a general overview of the feeling around a brand.

In this case, there was a higher percentage of negative conversation around both brands compared to the other rivalries we have previously covered.

One way to understand the topics of complaint and the higher rate of negative mentions is to dive into the data for a qualitative analysis. We can also discover how people are comparing the two services by evaluating the mentions that feature both brands.

@FedExHelp just pick a date a stick to it. I’m sticking with my guys @UPS they got my back. ✌️

— William (@_justhatguy) April 8, 2016

 

Mentions of both brands can highlight why somebody is thinking of switching from one company to another…

@UPS @UPSHelp may have the worst customer service in the business. Time to start using fedex

— Pavluchuk & Assoc (@Jpavllc) April 11, 2016

 

As these examples show, for all the benefits e-commerce brings, a late delivery or poor customer service when something goes wrong can be hugely frustrating.

The growing use of Twitter for customer service is largely improving customer experience, but it leaves the frustrated few complaining in public view.

---

A quantitative analysis

If we are going to get to the bottom of this social showdown we will need to undertake a quantitative analysis. To do that, we picked some of the most common annoyances of package delivery, as mentioned in the dataset.

We created rules in Brandwatch Analytics to categorize the mentions and find how much negative conversation fell into several categories.

We searched for mentions of late deliveries, missed deliveries, damaged deliveries, rude drivers, and poor customer service.

Clearly UPS receives more mentions in all five negative topics. At first, it appears that FedEx is the clear winner.

However, if we account for the fact that UPS took 60% of the overall conversation, a different story emerges.

If the two brands delivered an equally good level of service we would expect the 60/40 conversation split to be repeated in each of the complaints categories.

By weighting the complaints against the benchmark we can see the increase or decrease in complaints compared to the average.

Now we can see that there are more UPS mentions around damaged and missing deliveries. More people reference FedEx when complaining of poor customer service, rude delivery drivers, or late deliveries.

This implies that FedEx is better at the delivery side of the business, whereas UPS has a better consumer facing service than it’s rival.

---

The final verdict

It’s a close call, with both brands succeeding in some categories and falling behind in others.

UPS has more followers and fans and gains a higher share of voice between the two brands, taking 60% of the conversation.

FedEx is the winner when it comes to general sentiment, with 64.8% positive compared to UPS with 56%.

Finally, looking at common grievances with parcel delivery firms, UPs has more mentions in two categories and FedEx has three. However, the swing towards FedEx is more pronounced in the three it loses, so we’re calling this one a win for UPS.

For now, UPS narrowly delivers the win. With a race this close the momentum could easily swing back the other way.

---